François Ozon's first foray into crime comedy boasts bags of charm and a biting feminist edge.
In a high-profile legal case, the accused stands before two courts: the judgement of a jury and the court of public opinion. Though the first may rule unanimously, the second is a more complicated affair where permissible innocence can be branded guilty. Today, court cases have become a source of entertainment like a reality show that creates overnight celebrityhood. At this intersection of criminality and fame, François Ozon’s The Crime is Mine plays out as the prolific French director’s first foray into crime comedy.
Set in a romanticised 1930s Paris, the film revolves around whether struggling actress Madeline Rosalie (newcomer Nadia Tereszkiewicz) held the revolver that killed a lecherous producer (Jean-Christophe Bouvet). According to Madeleine, the producer sexually assaulted her before she escaped his mansion. But the police, who fumbled together evidence, deemed Madeleine the prime suspect. Luckily, Pauline (Rebecca Marder), Madeleine’s best friend and fellow broke roommate, happens to be a lawyer. Together, the dramatic blonde and pragmatic brunette face the judicial system head-on in an engaging battle of wits.
With Pauline as her defence counsel and de facto publicity manager, Madeline gives the performance of a lifetime in the dock with rehearsed monologue lines and carefully selected costumes. Her self-defence declaration has her ascending to stardom, opening a new world of fame and notoriety.
Simultaneously, Ozon has a whale of a time poking holes in the corrupt justice system. He indulges in opulent sets and smart staging as the film brandishes its biting feminist edge. Also, with nods to Billy Wilder (a Mauvaise Graine cinema trip) and the playful inclusion of genre tropes (iris transitions and twiddling moustaches prompt a giggle), Ozon sprinkles The Crime is Mine with Parisian cinematic history.
The city of lights twinkles as never before as the blossoming film star and the sought-after lawyer still choose to live together and even share a bathtub. The carefully penned intimacy between Madeline and Pauline adds a freshness to the thirties context and amplifies the latter’s desire to keep her friend from the slammer.
Yet halfway through, the energy of the jaunty screwball romp begins to flag. Then, the eccentric silent cinema star Odette Chaumette (Isabelle Huppert) enters. She arrives with a flurry of colour and chaos, draped in fur and feathers like a French Cruella De Vil (a Dalmatian even growls at her) claiming to know the truth about the crime. Her extravagant presence brings an absurdity that abruptly ends any meandering. Tereszkiewicz and Marder delight as a double act, but it’s Huppert who steals the show with a cunning smile.
Published 21 Oct 2024
Courtroom dramas are hot this year.
An effervescent who[didn’t do] it with Ozon’s playful, stylistic flair.
A feminist crime comedy that needs more Isabelle Huppert!
Little White Lies was established in 2005 as a bi-monthly print magazine committed to championing great movies and the talented people who make them. Combining cutting-edge design, illustration and journalism, we’ve been described as being “at the vanguard of the independent publishing movement.” Our reviews feature a unique tripartite ranking system that captures the different aspects of the movie-going experience. We believe in Truth & Movies.
